If you're comparing the top 10 roofing companies in Broken Arrow, OK, you're probably dealing with hail damage, an estimate that feels too high, or a roof that's simply worn out. We checked licensing status, review patterns, warranty terms, and service area for each company below so you can shortlist a contractor in minutes instead of days. As a roofing and exterior contractor working Broken Arrow roofs year-round, we've also added the local details most lists skip, like how the 25% roofing rule actually works and what Oklahoma's hail numbers mean for your material choice.
Quick Overview: Best Roofing Companies by Category
The right roofing company depends on what matters most to you: speed, price, warranty length, or specialty materials. Here's a fast snapshot before the full profiles below.
Best Overall Roofer
Erie Home combines strong reviews, active licensing, and consistent storm-restoration results across the Tulsa metro.
Best for Emergency Repairs
Roughneck Roofing is known for fast tarp-and-repair response after Oklahoma hail and wind events.
Best for Designer Roofing
Capital Roofing offers one of the widest selections of architectural shingles and specialty profiles for curb-appeal-focused homeowners.
Best Range of Services
Outdoor Creations Roofing & Solar pairs roofing with siding, gutters, and solar installs under one contract.
Best Value Roofer
Pro-Tech Roofing Inc offers competitive estimates without dropping down a material grade.
Want a second opinion before you sign anything? Get a free estimate from our Broken Arrow crew before committing to a bid.
Full List: Top 10 Roofing Companies in Broken Arrow, OK (2026)
1. Erie Home
Erie Home has built a national reputation for storm-damage restoration, and its Broken Arrow crews focus heavily on insurance-claim roof replacements. The company lists active Oklahoma registration and general liability coverage on its site, and it specializes in impact-resistant shingle systems backed by what it advertises as a lifetime material warranty. Homeowners frequently mention responsive project managers and clear claim-process guidance.
What sets Erie Home apart locally is how closely it coordinates with insurance adjusters during the claim process. Confirm current local review scores directly before booking, since ratings shift month to month.
2. C&A Roofing & Construction
C&A Roofing & Construction has served the Tulsa metro for over a decade, handling both residential roof replacement and smaller repair jobs. The company says it is licensed and insured, with a specialty in asphalt shingle systems and minor structural repairs tied to roof decking.
Where C&A stands out is its willingness to take on smaller repair-only jobs that larger crews sometimes turn away.
3. 1st Priority Roofing - Tulsa
1st Priority Roofing - Tulsa focuses on storm restoration and insurance-claim management, pairing homeowners with adjusters throughout the process. The company advertises current Oklahoma contractor registration and emphasizes metal and architectural shingle upgrades.
The company's biggest advantage is an in-house claims team that helps reduce paperwork friction for homeowners filing hail or wind claims.
4. Roughneck Roofing
Roughneck Roofing built its name on rapid emergency tarping and repair after severe weather, making it a go-to for same-week service requests. The company says it is licensed and insured, with a service radius covering Broken Arrow and surrounding Tulsa County communities.
What makes Roughneck different is responsiveness: crews often arrive within 24-48 hours of a storm for temporary protection. If you need that kind of speed right now, our emergency roof repair team also covers Broken Arrow.
5. Outdoor Creations Roofing & Solar
Outdoor Creations Roofing & Solar expanded beyond traditional roofing into solar panel installs, gutters, and siding, giving homeowners a single point of contact for exterior projects. The company lists active licensing and markets itself as a full-service roofing contractor.
Its strongest selling point is bundling solar-ready roof decking with new roof installations for homeowners planning future solar upgrades. If you're only looking to handle gutters alongside a reroof, our gutter services page outlines what's typically included in that kind of pairing.
6. Pro-Tech Roofing Inc
Pro-Tech Roofing Inc has operated in the Broken Arrow area for years, focusing on mid-range asphalt shingle replacements with itemized estimates. The company says it is licensed and insured, and its pricing tends to land below several larger regional competitors without dropping material grade.
Homeowners most often mention straightforward communication as the reason they'd call Pro-Tech again.
7. Burggraf Roofing
Burggraf Roofing is a longer-standing local name known for traditional asphalt shingle work and smaller repair jobs across Broken Arrow neighborhoods. The company carries current state registration and tends to serve a tighter local radius rather than the broader metro.
The edge Burggraf brings is deep familiarity with older Broken Arrow roof structures and permitting requirements.
8. Proof Construction LLC
Proof Construction LLC handles both roofing and broader exterior remodeling, including siding and window work alongside roof replacement. The company holds active licensing and positions itself as a one-stop option for homeowners combining a reroof with other exterior upgrades.
What makes Proof worth a call is flexible project bundling that can reduce overall contractor coordination for larger renovations.
9. Shamrock Roofing and Construction Tulsa
Shamrock Roofing and Construction Tulsa specializes in storm restoration and insurance-claim roof replacements, with a focus on impact-resistant shingle upgrades. The company says it is licensed and insured and serves Broken Arrow as part of a wider Tulsa-metro footprint.
One notable practice is offering upgraded impact-rated materials as a standard recommendation rather than an upsell.
10. Capital Roofing
Capital Roofing rounds out the list with a focus on architectural and designer shingle installations for homeowners prioritizing curb appeal. The company maintains current licensing and offers an expanded color and texture selection compared to several competitors on this list.
The detail that stands out is a showroom-style consultation process that helps homeowners visualize finished results before committing.
Before signing with any of the companies above, verify current registration status and request references directly. Ratings and crew availability change throughout the year, and you can browse real completed work on our projects page for comparison.
| Company | Price Tier | Specialty | Advertised Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Erie Home | Mid-High | Storm restoration, insurance claims | Lifetime materials |
| C&A Roofing & Construction | Mid | Asphalt shingles, small repairs | 10-20 years |
| 1st Priority Roofing - Tulsa | Mid-High | Insurance claim management | 25-30 years |
| Roughneck Roofing | Mid | Emergency repair, storm response | 10-15 years |
| Outdoor Creations Roofing & Solar | High | Roofing + solar/siding bundles | 20-25 years |
| Pro-Tech Roofing Inc | Low-Mid | Value asphalt replacement | 10-20 years |
| Burggraf Roofing | Low-Mid | Local repair, older homes | 10-15 years |
| Proof Construction LLC | Mid | Roofing + exterior remodeling | 15-25 years |
| Shamrock Roofing and Construction Tulsa | Mid-High | Impact-resistant upgrades | 25-30 years |
| Capital Roofing | Mid-High | Architectural/designer shingles | 20-30 years |
Warranty terms and price tiers above are general ranges based on each company's own marketing. Confirm exact terms in writing before signing a contract.
How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Broken Arrow?
Material grade is the single biggest driver of cost, followed by roof size, pitch, and tear-off complexity.
| Material | Cost per Square Foot | Typical Total (Average Home) |
|---|---|---|
| Standard asphalt shingles | $4.50-$7 | $5,500-$12,000 |
| Architectural/designer shingles | $7-$10 | $9,000-$16,000 |
| Metal roofing | $9-$16 | $14,000-$25,000+ |
Steep pitches, multiple layers of old shingles, and extensive decking repair all push these numbers higher. These figures shift with material availability and labor demand, so a written estimate from a registered roofer remains the only reliable way to pin down your actual cost.
For project planning, browse our roof replacement services page for a closer look at what's typically included in a quote, or request a free estimate to get a number specific to your home.
How To Choose a Roofing Company in Broken Arrow
Ask about materials first. Confirm shingle brand, warranty class, and whether impact-resistant options are available for hail-prone areas like Broken Arrow. A contractor unwilling to specify materials in writing is a warning sign worth taking seriously.
Check recent references, not just star ratings. Ask for two or three local addresses completed within the past year, and look for patterns across reviews rather than isolated five-star praise.
Insist on an itemized estimate. A detailed written estimate should break down labor, materials, disposal, and warranty terms separately. Vague, bundled estimates tend to lead to change-order surprises mid-project.
Verify registration before you sign anything. Oklahoma requires roofing contractors to register with the state regardless of project size, and checking a contractor's status takes only a few minutes through the Oklahoma Construction Industries Board's roofing lookup tool. Confirming this upfront protects you if a dispute or warranty issue arises later.
For general guidance on vetting contractors before you commit, start from our homepage.
Signs Your Roof Needs Repair or Replacement
Most roof failures don't happen overnight. They show warning signs weeks or months before a leak forces an emergency call.
- Roof age. Asphalt shingle roofs typically last 15-25 years, while architectural shingles and metal roofing can stretch to 30-50 years depending on installation quality and weather exposure.
- Leaks or water stains. Brown or yellow staining on ceilings or attic rafters usually signals an active leak, even if you can't see water during dry weather.
- Exposed roof decking. When shingles have worn thin enough that the wood underneath is visible, the roof has moved past minor repair territory.
- Cracked, broken, or missing shingles. A handful of missing shingles after a storm might be a simple repair, but widespread cracking often points toward broader storm damage worth a full inspection.
- Flashing deterioration. Rusted, lifted, or cracked flashing around chimneys, vents, and skylights is one of the most common sources of slow, hard-to-trace leaks.
- A sagging roofline. A visibly sagging or wavy roof is a structural red flag, not a cosmetic one, and warrants an immediate professional inspection.
If you're noticing any of these signs, our roof inspection and roof repair teams serve Broken Arrow and can tell you whether you're looking at a patch or a full replacement.
Which Roofing Material Is Best for Broken Arrow Homes?
Oklahoma recorded 369 major hail events of 1 inch or larger in 2025, the third-most of any state in the country, which is exactly why hail resistance matters more here than in most of the U.S. The best roofing material for Broken Arrow balances that hail exposure with wind performance and heat tolerance, since the area also deals with long, humid summers and occasional tornado-strength wind.
Impact-resistant shingles rated Class 4 tend to perform best against hail, while metal roofing offers stronger wind resistance and a longer lifespan at a higher upfront cost. Standard three-tab asphalt shingles remain the most budget-friendly option, but they generally hold up worse against repeated hail impacts than impact-resistant or architectural alternatives.
Homeowners weighing impact resistance for insurance purposes should ask contractors about FORTIFIED Roof standards, a voluntary above-code construction standard that some insurers factor into premium discounts. Our roof installation team can walk you through which materials qualify. For a deeper material comparison outside Broken Arrow, see our guide on rubber roofing options in Piedmont, OK.
Best Time of Year to Replace a Roof in Oklahoma
Late spring through early fall generally offers the most reliable roofing season in Oklahoma, since most shingle materials need moderate temperatures to seal and cure properly. Many contractors see their busiest stretch right after spring hailstorms, which can extend scheduling wait times into summer.
Fall is often the better choice for homeowners with flexibility, since storm-driven demand has usually eased and temperatures remain mild enough for proper shingle adhesion. Winter installations are possible but riskier, since cold temperatures slow shingle sealing and increase the chance of handling damage during installation.
If your roof is already compromised, waiting for an "ideal" season isn't worth the risk of ongoing leaks or structural damage. A registered roofer can often install in less-than-ideal weather when necessary, with some added precautions.
Will Home Insurance Cover Your Roof Replacement?
Most homeowners insurance policies cover roof replacement when the damage stems from a covered peril like hail, wind, or falling debris, but they typically exclude damage caused by age, neglect, or lack of maintenance. Oklahoma's frequent hail events mean storm-damage claims are common here, though insurers increasingly scrutinize claims more closely than in past years.
A homeowners insurance roof claim usually starts with documenting damage through photos and a professional inspection. Adjusters sometimes miss less-visible damage that an experienced roofer can identify, which is one reason several companies on this list emphasize claims assistance as part of their service.
Coverage details vary significantly by policy, so review your specific policy language around wear-and-tear exclusions and depreciation before assuming full replacement cost will be covered. A contractor can advocate for a fair assessment, but the insurer makes the final coverage determination.
FAQ
What Are the Top Five Roofing Companies in Broken Arrow?
Based on the full list above, the top five are Erie Home, Roughneck Roofing, 1st Priority Roofing - Tulsa, Shamrock Roofing and Construction Tulsa, and Capital Roofing, chosen for their combination of licensing, storm-response speed, and insurance-claim experience. The remaining five are still worth a quote, especially for budget-focused or smaller repair projects.
Is It Better to Hire a Local Roofing Company Instead of a National Chain?
Local roofers typically offer faster response times and more personal accountability within the community, while national chains sometimes provide stronger standardized warranties. For most Broken Arrow homeowners, a well-reviewed local company offers the best balance of responsiveness and local weather-damage knowledge.
How Long Does a Roof Typically Last?
Lifespan varies by material, generally ranging from 15-25 years for standard asphalt shingles up to 40-50 years for metal roofing. Local hail frequency can shorten these ranges if a roof isn't rated for impact resistance.
What Is the 25% Rule for Roofing?
It's often treated as a hard nationwide code requirement, but it isn't one anymore in most places. The provision that forced a full roof replacement once repairs passed 25% of a roof section was removed from the International Building Code and International Residential Code in their 2003 editions. Today, the current IRC reroofing section generally just requires that repairs beyond a small patch meet current reroofing standards, like full tear-off and proper underlayment, rather than triggering an automatic whole-roof mandate. Some cities or insurers still apply their own 25% thresholds as policy, so confirm directly with Broken Arrow's permitting office or your adjuster before assuming it applies to your project.
Do I Need a Permit to Replace a Roof in Broken Arrow?
Most roof replacements in Broken Arrow require a building permit, and Oklahoma separately requires the contractor doing the work to carry active state roofing registration regardless of the job's size. Ask your contractor to confirm both before work starts, and verify their registration yourself using the state's roofing contractor lookup.
Is $30,000 Too Much for a Roof?
For most standard Broken Arrow homes, $30,000 is on the high end, typically reserved for large roofs, complex rooflines, or premium metal roofing systems rather than standard asphalt replacement. Based on the cost breakdown above, a $30,000 quote is worth questioning unless it includes metal materials, extensive decking repair, or a notably large or steep roof.
Still comparing options? Get a free estimate from our Broken Arrow roofing team and we'll give you a straight answer on scope and price before you sign with anyone.
